What Actually Makes a Therapist Better? The Answer Isn’t Years on the Job.

What Actually Makes a Therapist Better? The Answer Isn’t Years on the Job.

The longest waits for children’s mental health support hit a record. Here’s what the research says about getting better at helping.

Most people, asked to choose between a therapist with twenty-five years behind them and one who qualified last year, pick the first without hesitating.

The research is less sure.

In 2016, a team led by Simon Goldberg published a study in the Journal of Counseling Psychology that put that assumption to the test. They followed client outcomes over time and asked a simple question: do therapists get better as they gain experience? On average, they did not. If anything, outcomes declined very slightly as experience grew, though some individual therapists did improve.

The finding is debated, and it doesn’t mean experience counts for nothing. But it sits uncomfortably next to what most of us assume. If years in the room don’t reliably produce better outcomes, something else must.

What the research points to

A smaller study, by Daryl Chow, Scott Miller and colleagues in 2015, came at the question from the other side. It asked what the more effective therapists actually did differently. The factor most clearly linked to better client outcomes was not years of experience. It was time spent in deliberate practice.

Deliberate practice comes from Anders Ericsson’s research on expert performance. Ericsson and his colleagues studied violinists at a Berlin music academy and found that what set the best apart from the merely good was not talent alone. It was hours spent practising alone, on the specific things they found hardest.

Chow’s study was small and needs replicating. But it points to a question that is rarely asked about the people we trust with our minds: where do they practise?

For a violinist, the answer is simple. A practice room. For a trainee therapist, a failed attempt happens in front of a real person in real distress.

The gap that arrives first

Picture a trainee on their first placement. Ten minutes into a session, a client says something that doesn’t fit anything in the textbook. The trainee has read the theory. They have never had to decide, in real time, what to say next.

Role-play with a classmate is a standard training tool. But it depends on a classmate who is available, willing, and able to play a convincing patient.

Meanwhile, demand is not waiting for anyone to be ready. In March 2026, NHS England data, analysed by YoungMinds, showed 932,822 under-18s in England with an active mental health referral. There were 134,837 new referrals in that month alone, a record. And the longest waits ran to 1,006 days, also a record.

Among adults, the long-term direction is the same. Common mental disorders in England rose from around 15 to 16% in the early 1990s to around 23% by the mid-2020s, according to NHS adult mental health survey data presented in the independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism, published in March 2026. Among 16 to 24 year olds, NHS survey data show the rate rose from 17.5% in 2007 to 25.8% in 2023/4. In the US, Gallup found that 29% of adults reported a lifetime diagnosis of depression in 2023, up from 19.6% in 2015.

These are different measures in different countries and can’t be compared directly. They do point the same way. They also measure demand, not the number of practitioners. But a wait of 1,006 days is what it looks like when demand and capacity have come apart.

Training more practitioners is essential, and it is slow, because qualifying takes years. In the meantime, each new practitioner has to learn fast. The question is how much of that learning can happen somewhere a mistake costs nothing but a lesson.

A place to practise

Chomi companion’s practice mode was built for that.

A practitioner chooses from nineteen Jungian work types, including shadow integration, active imagination, dream amplification and inner child work. Then they choose how to practise. They can take the patient’s seat and experience how a work type feels from the inside. Or they can let Chomi companion simulate the patient’s responses and rehearse the encounter from the practitioner’s chair. Either way, no real patient relationship is at stake.

There is also autochat, in which Chomi companion carries out a full conversation using a chosen work type across a set number of turns while the practitioner watches. It shows how depth work unfolds across an extended exchange and how it moves between psychological territory. For someone new to Jungian work, it is a way to see the framework in action before using it with a client.

It is a rehearsal space. A trainee can test an interpretation, see how it lands, refine their approach and build pattern recognition, all before a real client is in the room.

One limit is worth stating plainly. No study has tested whether practising in Chomi companion’s practice mode improves client outcomes, and this article does not claim one has. The claim is narrower. The research suggests deliberate practice matters. Practice mode gives practitioners somewhere to do it without a real person on the other side.

Beyond the practice room

Chomi companion for therapists is open to therapists, counsellors, social workers and others in supportive clinical roles. For practitioners whose clients choose to use Chomi companion between appointments, sharing is always opt-in, controlled by the client and revocable at any time. What surfaced between sessions can be in the room when the next one begins.

Chomi companion is a Jungian companion, developed by clinical psychologists and forensic researchers including Dr. Lorraine Sheridan, a forensic psychologist whose risk-assessment form was, until recently, used in every harassment case reported to police in England and Wales. It does not diagnose, prescribe or make clinical claims.

Two things are worth stating plainly.

Chomi companion is designed not to drift. Its Jungian grounding, its character and the way it engages with what is brought to it are built to stay consistent across every conversation. For a practitioner rehearsing an approach, that consistency matters: the practice partner is designed to behave the same way each time.

And conversations stay on your device by default. They do not reach nRich’s servers unless you explicitly choose to share them. Privacy is a founding architectural principle, built into how the system works rather than promised in a policy.

Chomi companion also has hardcoded crisis signposting. At defined thresholds, when a conversation indicates acute risk, it always directs to professional crisis services. This is built into the architecture and cannot be configured away.

Go back to the first question. Twenty-five years, or last year’s graduate? The research suggests a better question may be: which of them keeps practising?

The waiting lists won’t shorten by themselves. Practitioners who have somewhere to practise before they sit with someone in distress are one part of the answer.

https://chomi.world/

Sources:

Goldberg, S. B., et al. (2016). Do psychotherapists improve with time and experience? A longitudinal analysis of outcomes in a clinical setting. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 63(1), 1–11.

Chow, D. L., et al. (2015). The role of deliberate practice in the development of highly effective psychotherapists. Psychotherapy, 52(3), 337–345.